Podcast transcript:
Hello and Welcome to News From The Future, spoken by the eleven labs audio clone of Dr Catherine Ball.
In this new short series we will be focussing on Sleep. We all do it, and we all recognise when we have not had enough of it.
Dr Cath’s new book The Future of Sleep is out now and available globally in paperback, audiobook, and ebook formats.
Amazon link here.
We think you’ll get something life changing from it.
Today we are talking about something a bit controversial - Infant Sleep
Enjoy!
Infant sleep is one of the most misunderstood aspects of child development, with countless myths and misconceptions that can leave parents confused and overwhelmed. From the idea that babies should sleep through the night by a certain age to whether motion naps are restorative, these beliefs often stem more from cultural norms and commercial sleep programs than from scientific evidence. Let’s break down five of the most common myths about infant sleep and explore what research actually tells us.
To start, the notion that most babies “sleep through the night” is far from accurate. While parents often see this as a milestone, studies consistently show that night wakings are normal and persist well into toddlerhood. For example, a large Norwegian study involving over 55,000 infants found that nearly 70% of six-month-olds woke at least once during the night, and even at 18 months, more than 25% were still waking. Similarly, a 2020 Finnish study of 5,700 babies found that three- to eight-month-olds woke an average of more than twice per night, 12-month-olds woke 1.8 times, and 18- to 24-month-olds woke about once per night.
It’s important to note that these findings are based on parental reports, which may underestimate the true number of wakings. Parents might not always notice when their baby wakes briefly. When more objective methods, such as video recordings, are used, the data show even higher numbers. A 2001 study using video monitoring revealed that three-month-olds woke an average of three times per night, six-month-olds 3.5 times, nine-month-olds 4.7 times, and 12-month-olds 2.6 times. However, the good news is that as babies approach their second birthday, these night wakings tend to decrease naturally. By two years of age, only about 25% of children wake during the night.
That said, while frequent night wakings are common, they’re not always “normal.” The belief that children will continue waking unless they’re “taught” not to ignores the fact that most infants naturally consolidate their sleep over time. It also risks overlooking potential underlying health issues that could disrupt sleep. For instance, iron deficiency, which affects around 15% of toddlers in the U.S., has been linked to restless sleep and frequent night wakings. Other conditions, such as food allergies, gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), and ear infections, can also contribute to unsettled sleep. Additionally, sleep disorders like obstructive sleep apnea affect up to 6% of children and can cause frequent waking, particularly between the ages of two and six years. These examples highlight the importance of considering medical factors if a baby’s sleep seems unusually disrupted.
Another widespread misconception is the idea that most babies need 12 hours of uninterrupted sleep per night. This belief has been popularized by the “7-7” schedule, which assumes that anything less than 12 hours is inadequate. However, research suggests that this idealized schedule doesn’t reflect the reality for most children. An Australian study of 5,000 babies found that children from infancy to nearly five years old slept an average of 11 hours at night—not 12. Even the youngest group in the study, aged four to six months, averaged about 11 hours of nighttime sleep.
Sleep patterns also vary widely across cultures, challenging the notion of a universal “ideal” sleep duration. For instance, one study found that babies in Australia, Canada, the UK, and the U.S. slept around 10 hours per night on average, while babies in Taiwan, Hong Kong, and India slept closer to nine hours. These differences reflect cultural norms and parenting practices rather than biological needs. Even in societies that promote the 7-7 schedule, organizations like the American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommend total sleep (including naps) of 12-16 hours for four- to 12-month-olds and 11-14 hours for one- to two-year-olds. They don’t specify how much of this sleep should occur at night, and some researchers question the scientific basis for these recommendations.
The idea that motion naps—such as those taken in a stroller, sling, or car—are less restorative is another myth that lacks scientific support. In fact, some research suggests that motion naps may even be beneficial. A study on two-month-olds found that rocking helped babies fall asleep more easily and reduced crying. Similarly, babies with obstructive sleep apnea experienced fewer obstructive events when sleeping on rocking mattresses compared to stationary ones.
While no studies have directly examined infants’ brain activity during motion naps, research on adults provides some insights. Studies using electroencephalogram (EEG) monitoring have shown that gentle rocking increases the amount of time spent in deep sleep, helps people transition into deep sleep more quickly, enhances brain oscillations associated with memory consolidation, and reduces time spent in light sleep. These findings suggest that motion naps are not only restorative but may also promote healthy brain development. This makes sense when you consider that babies spend about 90% of their time in utero sleeping, much of it while being “rocked” by their mother’s movements.
Finally, the concept that “sleep breeds sleep” is another common misconception. While it’s true that overtired babies can become more stressed and harder to settle, the idea that more daytime sleep automatically leads to better nighttime sleep isn’t strongly supported by research. In fact, studies on older toddlers and preschoolers have found the opposite: napping during the day can make it harder for them to fall asleep at night and may lead to more night wakings.
For younger infants, the relationship between daytime and nighttime sleep is less clear. One study using actigraphy—a method that tracks sleep-wake patterns through wearable devices—found that for six- and 15-week-old babies, longer daytime naps didn’t affect nighttime sleep. However, by 24 weeks, longer naps were associated with slightly more nighttime sleep, but the difference was minimal. For example, an extra hour of daytime sleep resulted in just 14 additional minutes of nighttime sleep. It’s also possible that other factors, such as growth spurts, influenced these findings rather than the naps themselves.
This minimal impact of daytime sleep on nighttime sleep aligns with the concept of the sleep-wake homeostat, or “sleep pressure.” This biological mechanism drives the need for sleep based on how long a person (or baby) has been awake. If a baby sleeps too much during the day, their sleep pressure may not be high enough to make falling asleep at night easy. Ultimately, sleep needs are highly individual, and trying to “force” a baby to sleep more than their body requires is unlikely to be successful.
In conclusion, infant sleep is highly variable and influenced by a range of factors, from cultural norms to individual health conditions. While some myths persist, research shows that night wakings are common and decrease naturally over time, motion naps are restorative, and the relationship between daytime and nighttime sleep is complex. Parents should focus on understanding their baby’s unique sleep needs rather than adhering to rigid schedules or expectations. By approaching infant sleep with flexibility and an open mind, parents can better support their child’s natural development and well-being.
Please share this podcast with anyone you know who sleeps.
Thank you for supporting my work. Please follow me on LinkedIn or subscribe to my substack for more News From The Future
And please buy my book: The Future of Sleep.
Thank you.
Thanks for reading "News From The Future" with Dr Catherine Ball! This post is public so feel free to share it with anyone who sleeps.
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit drcatherineball.substack.com/subscribe