History of the Germans from the Middle Ages to Reunification

In June and July 1519, Martin Luther finally got the open debate he had been demanding, and it went badly for him. Johannes Eck, the formidable Ingolstadt theologian, used a quarrel with Luther's colleague Andreas Karlstadt to lure Luther to Leipzig, onto the territory of Duke George of Saxony.
This episode follows how the debate came about despite Rome's efforts to prevent it, the theatrics of the Wittenbergers' arrival, and how Eck steered Luther away from indulgences and towards papal authority. Pushed into a corner, Luther declared that some of Jan Hus's condemned teachings were "Christian and evangelical", and so that even a church council could err. In Leipzig that made him a Hussite and a heretic, and it turned Duke George into his implacable foe.
And yet Luther came out of it stronger. His pamphlets outsold Eck's, humanist satire made Eck a laughing stock, and the bull Exsurge Domine condemned him without arguing from scripture. With no way back, Luther began to link his fight with the papacy to his own search for a merciful God, which is where the Reformation proper begins.

Chapter

0:00 | Introduction: Lyndal Roper on Leipzig
1:24 | Supporting the show
2:48 | After Augsburg: Luther a de facto prisoner in Saxony
6:55 | Enter Johannes Eck, Luther's nemesis
9:41 | Rome plays for time: Karl von Miltitz and the imperial election
11:42 | Eck goes after Karlstadt
14:47 | Finding a venue: why Leipzig
18:57 | A football derby of the mind
19:45 | The Wittenbergers arrive (and Karlstadt lands in the mud)
24:04 | Eck versus Karlstadt on free will
25:12 | Luther's turn: Matthew 16:18 and the power of the popes
28:40 | Eck plays the Hus card
30:22 | "Some of Hus's theses are Christian and evangelical"
34:54 | The battle of the pamphlets
37:49 | Brand Luther: the economics of short pamphlets
40:51 | Humanist satire and the demolition of Eck
43:03 | Exsurge Domine
44:51 | Luther's reaction: the papacy as Antichrist
47:04 | How Rome pushed Luther towards the Reformation
49:11 | The other struggle: sinner and God
51:15 | Next time and related episodes

Books and sources
Lyndal Roper, Martin Luther: Renegade and Prophet (London: Bodley Head, 2016). 
Roland H. Bainton, Here I Stand: A Life of Martin Luther (New York and Nashville: Abingdon-Cokesbury, 1950). The portrait of Eck's 
Andrew Pettegree, Brand Luther: 1517, Printing, and the Making of the Reformation (New York: Penguin Press, 2015). 
Heinz Schilling, Martin Luther: Rebel in an Age of Upheaval, translated by Rona Johnston (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017). 
Volker Leppin, Martin Luther: A Late Medieval Life (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic). 

★ Support this podcast ★

In August 1518, Pope Leo X wrote to Frederick the Wise, Elector of Saxony, and demanded that he hand over “a son of iniquity”, Brother Martin Luther. A few weeks later Luther was on the road to Augsburg to face Cardinal Cajetan. It was arguably the most dangerous moment of his life, more dangerous even than Worms.
This episode follows how Luther got there and how close he came to the stake:
Fame: four groups (imperial reformers, humanists, friars and ordinary readers) each saw their own Luther.
Foes: the Dominicans, Johannes Eck, Luther’s old Erfurt teachers and, finally, the full weight of the Roman Church.
Friends: Melanchthon, Karlstadt, Cranach and Spalatin.
The Fat Marmot: a portrait of Frederick the Wise, the cautious, pious and remarkably peaceable prince who held Luther’s fate in his hands.
Augsburg: Luther’s meetings with Cajetan, one of the sharpest theologians of his age, and how they ended in shouting.
Flight: Luther’s escape through a gate in the city wall at night, and his discovery that Rome had condemned him before he was ever heard.
The final hour: a farewell dinner in Wittenberg on 1 December 1518, and two letters from the Elector that changed the course of the Reformation.
Further reading
Armin Kohnle, Friedrich der Weise (2024)
Roland H. Bainton, Here I Stand: A Life of Martin Luther
Support the show: History of the Germans is advertising-free thanks to listeners like you. Become a member at historyofthegermans.com/support.

★ Support this podcast ★

n spring 1518 Martin Luther assured Pope Leo X that he was a dutiful son of the Church. But was he still one?
 The 95 Theses were the perfect opening salvo: provocative, popular and, crucially, not obviously heretical.
 Archbishop Albrecht’s own theologians in Mainz refused to condemn them and passed the problem on to Rome.
 Then Luther did something new: he wrote the Sermon on Indulgences and Grace in punchy German for ordinary readers.
It became an early bestseller and helped create a mass market for public debate in print.
Tetzel’s Dominicans hit back with counter-theses, which Wittenberg students promptly burned.
Leo X tried to deal with it inside the Augustinian order, but at Heidelberg Luther’s brothers cheered him instead.
There he set out his theology of the cross and denied that fallen humans can earn salvation by their own free will.
After a defiant sermon on excommunication, Rome turned to the papal theologian Prierias, whose verdict was simple: whoever questions the pope is a heretic.
A summons to Rome followed, and a lone friar now faced the full weight of the papacy. 

★ Support this podcast ★

What if the most famous story of the Reformation has some massive holes? Was Tetzel really a snake oil salesman? Was Albrecht of Brandenburg and the Fuggers really after the indulgence contracts? Were the Germans been ripped off by the papacy more than anyone else? Who could believe that there is still room for new perspectives on this event?

★ Support this podcast ★

In this episode we will look at the first 35 years of Martin Luther’s life, from his birth in 1483 to a moment sometime between 1512 and 1519 when he achieved his great theological breakthrough. This is a crucial period in the history of the Reformation, a time when Luther struggled with what he called his “Anfechtungen”. Anfechtungen is one of these untranslatable German words like Schadenfreude and Gemütlichkeit. It is something more than a trial or tribulation, more of an existential assault on faith itself — an overwhelming, often visceral experience of doubt, terror, and despair before God, in which the sinner feels utterly exposed to divine judgment and abandoned by grace. Sounds quite painful. It was these “Anfechtungen” that brought about the cornerstone of his creed, that salvation is to be obtained through faith alone. It is the story how Protestantism is born in the head of just one man.

★ Support this podcast ★